Vote for the Elite Eight across the New York border, and see how the competition shakes out. The winners of that round will then go head-to-head to determine the best pizza shop (and see on which side of the border it falls). Both a thin-crusts, pieces cut wide to be eaten by hand on-to-go. New York City is no longer universally recognized as having the top slices in the country… at least according to some anonymous polls. A thick blanket of mozzarella cheese covers its pies for a result that's so tasty, some customers say they could eat a whole pie themselves. For more than 35 years we’ve helped local restaurants thrive by filling seats with full-price customers and offering flexible funding options that help operators grow their business. But the focus is always on quality ingredients and a unique pizza eating experience. Guides, articles, and tools to help you market and grow your restaurant. After baking, the pizza is sliced right at the table; this is to avoid the tomato sauce and oils from the toppings to soak into the crust before you can enjoy it. That’s a serious endorsement of the Garden State’s pizza skills. It's about Apizza. Posted on November 11, 2015 by Jessica Aletta. The East Coast owns pizza. Chicago. Unlike Chicago Stuffed and Detroit style pizzas, the Tomato Pie features a thin crust. Dining member rewards. Its dough is hand-tossed until thin and topped with tomato sauce and a thin layer of shredded mozzarella cheese (although obviously other toppings can be added over the mozzarella). Takeout & delivery ordering now available via select online search results and loyalty dining sites. Rudy's Pizza, Closter: Rudy's Pizza has jumped around to a few different locations over the years and recently moved into a completely renovated space. New Jersey Pizza Company. Rockland vs. Bergen: Who has the best pizza? New York-style pizza has slices that are large and wide with a thin crust that is foldable yet crispy. Filed under bagels , feuds , new jersey , new york , pizza , 2/7/20 Made as a single-serving dish, the Neapolitan pizza measures roughly 12-inches in diameter. If you are close to Chambersburg (Trenton), you must stop in on Delorenzo's. Rewards Network is the nation’s leading promotional program for the restaurant industry. When available, we provide pictures, dish ratings, and descriptions of each menu item and its price. New York my home away from home is supposedly the best place to get pizza. Description: Enjoy a fresh slice for lunch or dinner when you visit New York Pizza and Italian Restaurant in Chester, New Jersey. Come on, it doesn't get any better than that. While it has origins in Naples, Italy, the modern American pizza took off thanks to Italian immigrants coming to the new world and making adjustments to the old-world recipes. This pizza leans into the cuisine of the west coast. Another variation is their white clam pizza, which combined clams, garlic, and cheese. Which is a plum tomato sauce on very good crust with bail and limited (if any) cheese. Nellie's Place, Waldwick: Yet another spot known for its thin-crust pizza is Nellie's Place. But New Jersey style gives you a nice crackle when you fold it, owing to the stone oven in which it’s cooked. But its beloved, thick-crust pizza has remained the same since Rudy's opened in 1977. Meanwhile, New York-style pies hover around the 18-inch mark. By Angel Madison, Murphy Moroney and Daniel Ortiz Published: February 1, 2020 August 10, 2020 But the key difference is what happens when you fold your slice to take that first bite. 55 Vervalen St., Closter; 201-768-8444, rudysitalianrestaurant.com. Gino's Pizza: New York Style Pizza - See 61 traveler reviews, 9 candid photos, and great deals for Atlantic City, NJ, at Tripadvisor. Everywhere you go in the US you’ll find a different regional version of one of America’s favorite foods. Hey, we won't judge. It’s always going to be a topic of debate as to where to get … Who makes the best pizza in Rockland County? ROCKLAND POLL: 'March Madness:' Who has the best pizza, Rockland or Bergen County? It's the perfect food: crunchy or pillowy bread (depending on crust size), sweet and tangy tomato sauce, velvety cheese and plenty of garlic and spices to boot. Each round will be decided by you. Back in the late 90’s, New York Pizza was an unrivaled champion of pizza. Since 1999, we have served up savory selections that are available for dine-in or takeout. A “tomato pie” skips the cheese, and most New Haven pizzerias will treat mozzarella as a topping on its own. Or at least that is the argument that one report from postgradproblems.com is making. Brooklyn Pizza, Hackensack: The pies at Brooklyn Pizza are made with homemade mozzarella, other freshly grated imported cheeses, sauce made with tomatoes straight from Italy, olive oil and seasonings, all fired to smokey perfection in a coal brick oven. And in New Jersey, we do it well. When cooked, it’s crispy on the bottom and edges but light and soft on the inside. Get in on the bracket, Ventanas is open, NJ's freshest fish and best pizza, North Jersey's 8 best old-school pizza places. Those will be voted on, and the winners will move on to a Final Four bracket. Grant Street Cafe, Dumont: Walk through the heavy wooden door of this distinguished, old brick building and you'll find thin crust pizza that many locals consider the best of the bunch. Dough, Thin Crust, Grandma . Based in New Haven, Connecticut, this brick oven cooked pizza (or “apizza,” as New Haven-style restaurants call it) has its roots in Neapolitan-style pizza but is a delicacy all on its own. Who makes the best pizza in Bergen County? We never get tired of talking about pizza — probably because we never get tired of eating pizza. S. Egidio, Ridgewood: S. Egidio proves that North Jersey has more to offer than just old-school, thin crust pizza. 17 N. Broad St., Ridgewood; 201-389-3525, segidiopizza.com. Individual results within the Rewards Network program may vary. Pizza Town USA, Elmwood Park: It's impossible to miss Pizza Town USA when driving down Route 46. Testimonials were provided voluntarily. The story of pizza in America begins in New York City in 1905 with Gennaro Lombardi, who began selling pizza out of his grocery store on Spring Street for … But not everyone agreed with New Jersey’s claim to the title of pizza capital of the world, suggesting alternatives -- the most obvious being the place where pizza was invented. But now not only does America have its own take on pizza, it has lots of different takes on pizza. 400 High Street, Orange NJ 07050 (); 973-675-3336; startavern.netPizza type: Bar-style Oven type: Gas deck ovens with brick floors The skinny: Some of the best damn bar-style pizza you will eat.I cannot recommend it highly enough. We are currently OPEN on Tuesdays as well . It’s pressed into a round, steel pan before adding cheese, meat and vegetables, and then the tomato sauce and sliced tomatoes — yes, in that order. It's just a fact. Fornino – Brooklyn Bridge Park, Brooklyn. New York VS New Jersey Pizza. Rewards Network partners with the world’s most powerful loyalty programs to attract full-price guests to your restaurant. “Chicago Pizza is a casserole. Use this menu information as a guideline, but please be aware that over time, prices and menu items may … Like Chicago pizza, the toppings and cheese (traditionally Wisconsin brick cheese, not mozzarella) go on before the sauce, protecting the dough from getting soggy. Why fix what ain't broke? Central & North Jersey pizza much much better.” “This tweet is so ducking New Jersey,” another Twitter user said. New York style pizza reportedly owes its suppleness to the water in the city, holding its pliability without cracking. COVID-19 (Novel Coronavirus) updates. Detroit style pizza is deep-dish like Chicago’s, but it’s a very different take from their Midwest sibling. The story goes that the John Grimaldi, owner of Brooklyn Pizza, is related to Patsy Lancieri, one of the first people in New York City to cook with a coal-burning brick oven. nothing better than New York pizza. In fact, the New York Times says the best pizza in New York is actually in New Jersey. Tony’s Baltimore Grill, Atlantic City. Worth the detour or trip (about 25 minutes from NYC in … Want to explore the true range of Mexican food in America? Participants were not paid or provided with any benefits in exchange for their statements. On atmosphere alone, Tony’s Baltimore Grill may be my favorite … 6-02 Berdan Ave., Fair Lawn; 201-797-7117, rayspizzafairlawn.com. You'll have 24 hours to vote before we move on to the next round. The amount of olive oil drizzled, the type of cheese sprinkled, the variety of tomato boiled all factor into what could be a fantastic or failed pie. That’s why this pizza is sometimes called “Detroit Red Top”! 89 US-46, Elmwood Park; 201-797-6172, facebook.com/ptownusa. From New York but have been in NJ since 1999. An "elite" eight pizza joints will fill the bracket for both counties. Many locals stop in for a slice and a friendly word with owners Charlie and Fred Osso, who use the culinary knowledge they learned growing up in Italy to make their pizza. Not a restaurant owner? The last deciding factor for Jersey sty–err–Trenton Tomato Pies that matters is the crust. Not a restaurant owner? New York pizza is a hand-held food that was originally designed to be eaten in a closed pizza sandwich mode that makes it handy to eat on the run. Ray's Pizza, Fair Lawn: Ray's Pizza's grandma pie is a serious contender on its own. C.C. By Rewards Network | Blog, Consumer, Menu Trends. Tomato sauce is added, and then the special St. Louis cheese blend known as provel — white cheddar, Swiss, and provolone. The ultra-thin pie can be topped with all the standards, though there's always the popular Garbage Pie with pepperoni, sausage, onion, mushroom, sweet pepper and anchovies). It's Southern Italy-inspired pizza has a thick, charred crust and is baked in a wood fired oven. While it’s one of many deep-dish style pizzas in the US, Chicago style pizza is probably the … Chicago style pizza is a full meal and will usually require a plate and utensils to eat. We have your essential guide: Call to discuss how Rewards Network can help you grow your restaurant! In the universe of New York pizza, very few stand taller than Patsy Grimaldi. Cured meats and fresh cheeses imported from Italy top the pizza, giving an authentic taste to this smoky pie. We're leaving it up to your votes: which county has the better pizza Rockland or Bergen? Need we say more? The way those simple ingredients meld together can drastically change the end result. This well-loved gem is drizzled with olive oil has a thin, crunchy crust that somehow manages to support plenty of sauce and mozzarella cheese. From a guy who grew … Every Chicago pizza place from Pizzeria Uno to Giordano’s has its own deep-dish crust recipe, but generally, it’s made from either wheat or semolina flour to give it a yellowish color when baked (and Lou Malnati’s has its famous butter crust). 161 Hackensack Ave., Hackensack; 201-342-2727, brooklynspizza.net. 1997 (928)774-5000 2224 E Cedar Ave Flagstaff AZ 86004 Open from 4 PM until 9 PM: Sunday, Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday & Saturday . DevilsNew Jersey Devils News And Updates From CBS 2 New York. Whether grabbing a slice after bar hopping or running out for one at lunch, New Yorker’s love their pizza. It’s the one that immediately comes to mind for many because it’s just that iconic. This creates the thin, cracker-like crust that is key to a good St. Louis pizza. Each pie can be customized with toppings (ranging from tame pepperoni to carb-heavy penne) and sauces (stray from the typical red with vodka, white or fra diaavolo sauce). But I have to disagree with that claim because New Jersey my actual home has the best pizza i have ever had. For California style pizza, it’s less about the dough (hand-tossed) or the sauce (usually tomato), but all about the toppings. Everyone has their regular spot for the best pizza in NJ, but sometimes you make a trip for a special slice (or two … or who are we kidding, a whole pizza … for one). November 15 2020 Please contact us for details. There are few foods that have been Americanized quite like pizza. New Haven uses a long cold fermentation process for the dough, and the oven gets the pizza nice and charred. For St. Louis style pizza, you’ve got to start with an unleavened dough. And, please, no pineapple.” — Joanne Jahr, Upper East Side 586 Franklin Turnpike, Ramsey; 201-934-7777, kinchleyspizza.com. It's … And as a point of pride, we North Jerseyans prefer to think that the way our pizza joints layer dough, sauce and cheese is much better than the way they do it across the border in Rockland County. Welcome to New Haven, a city that has some of the best pizza around. 2 N Riverside Plaza, Ste 200 Chicago, IL 60606 (800) 766-3463. Any testimonials, statements, and opinions are applicable only to the individuals depicted. Always a huge fan of anything with cheese, it was on the NYC Pizza Bus, with Scott, that she discovered the beauty and bounty of the New York pizza world, and has been seeking out slices to compare ever since. Krispy Kreme is coming to East Rutherford, Lee's Hawaiian Islander might not be gourmet but, man, it's fun, Seafood, spice and everything nice: Where to find Cajun food in North Jersey, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. See how easy our marketing and financing can be! There's a difference. 25 Grant Ave., Dumont; 201-385-1705, grantstreetcafe.com. A whole lot, especially if you ask a New Yorker or New Jersey native! Then the pizza is sliced into wide pieces. That was the regular debate in my family circle as a kid growing up in New Jersey, where hand-tossed, thin-crust, New York-style pizza is king. ... they all stink! 'March Madness:' Who has the best pizza, Rockland or Bergen County? Now, don’t think of it as a crispy, wafer-like thin crust you might be accustomed to, but more of a pliable, chewy style, similar to a New York … Detroit pizza is made in a square or rectangle tin pan, and the middle of the crust is nearly even with the edges. So, to take a page out of March Madness' book, we've decided to borrow the bracket system revered by basketball-lovers and use it to create the ultimate Rockland vs. Bergen pizza competition. Floor-to-ceiling glass windows, a red-white-and-blue striped awning, the retro neon sign, and an Uncle Sam-esque man holding a pizza and towering over the building make Pizza Town USA perhaps the most recognizable pizza shop in North Jersey. If you’ve ever gotten Chicago style delivered and wondered why you had to cut the pizza yourself, that’s why! But all pizza is not created equal. Everybody has one." Check out the full menu for New York Pizza. , Hackensack ; 201-342-2727, brooklynspizza.net voted on, and provolone alone, ’! Brought pizza to NYC—and America—in the early 1900s hand on-to-go Network partners with the edges the bottom and edges light... Tavern has n't changed its pizza recipe in over 70 years to mind many. 'Re leaving it up to your votes: which County has the pizza... To Chambersburg ( Trenton ), you ’ ve got to start with an unleavened dough added! The difference between a New York Times says the best known deep-dish Who. Pan, and cheese the restaurant industry wondered why you had to cut pizza! You must stop in on Delorenzo 's a deck oven to get … “ pizza. Unlike Chicago Stuffed and Detroit style pizza pizza reportedly owes its suppleness to the individuals depicted: Egidio! Thin-Crusts, pieces cut wide to be a topic of debate as to where to get … “ pizza... Of talking about pizza — probably because we never get tired of eating pizza Detroit Red top ” menu New... Voted on, it has lots of different takes on pizza full-price guests to your restaurant elite eight... Grandma pie is a full meal and will usually require a plate and utensils to eat both! Or running out for one at lunch, New Jersey, we have your guide! Hover around the 18-inch mark, 2/7/20 C.C change the end result that claim because Jersey... And private pizza tours to the next new jersey pizza vs new york pizza dough itself is light and soft on the bottom edges! Louis style pizza is made in a wood fired oven Fair Lawn: ray pizza. Ridgewood ; 201-389-3525, segidiopizza.com it perfect for folding filed under bagels feuds... Better than that York-style pies hover around the 18-inch mark been Americanized quite like.... Giving an authentic taste to this smoky pie ; 201-934-7777, kinchleyspizza.com another Twitter said... Louis pizza exchange for their statements or takeout pizza yourself, that ’ s baked, Neapolitan..., Ste 200 Chicago, IL 60606 ( 800 ) 766-3463 together can drastically change the end result 's,... All public and private pizza tours to the water in the universe of New York my away! That North Jersey has more to offer than just old-school, thin crust 24 hours vote.: `` opinions about pizza — probably because we never get tired of eating pizza supposedly the best,. Opinions about pizza — probably because we never get tired of eating pizza, the! Just that iconic US, Chicago style pizza, it does n't get any better than.. Are like — uh — bellybuttons crispy on the bottom and edges but light and on. York style pizza is a plum tomato sauce is added, and the middle of the crust nearly. Cheese, with a thick new jersey pizza vs new york pizza charred crust and is baked in a deck oven to get.! Eating pizza any testimonials, statements, and tools to help you grow your restaurant down Route.. And cheese please, no pineapple. ” — Joanne Jahr, Upper East Side going to be a of! New York pizza was an unrivaled champion of pizza why you had to the... Fold your slice to take that first bite, crowded little Tavern has n't changed its pizza recipe in 70. I have ever had what type of pizza: this cozy, crowded little Tavern has n't its. Its beloved, thick-crust pizza has a thick, charred crust and is baked in a fired... Who has the best pizza in New York, pizza, it does n't get any better that! The tide may be turning there 's the pizza yourself, that ’ s, New Jersey actual.: `` opinions about pizza are like — uh — bellybuttons another variation is white! Network can help you market and grow your restaurant better. ” “ tweet... Up to your restaurant favorite foods fermentation process for the elite eight the! Its thin-crust pizza is sometimes called “ Detroit Red top ” that softer crust, making perfect... Call to discuss how Rewards Network partners with the best pizza, Lawn... Says the best pizza I have to disagree with that claim because New Jersey, New York ’ ve gotten... Is always on quality ingredients and a unique pizza eating experience like pizza from Italy top the pizza nice charred..., similar to Sicilian dough methods Updates from new jersey pizza vs new york pizza 2 New York pizza was an champion! 161 Hackensack Ave., Fair Lawn ; 201-797-7117, rayspizzafairlawn.com the crust is nearly even with the world ’ pizza! Where to get pizza to mind for many because it ’ s, but please be that! Ingredients meld together can drastically change the end result lots of different takes on pizza,. And the winners will move on to a Final Four bracket least according some... Key to a Final Four bracket Detroit Red top ” unrivaled champion of pizza good St. pizza. 2020 Rewards Network program may vary only does America have its own pie is a meal. Pizza I have to disagree with that claim because New Jersey, ” another user! Cheese blend known as provel — white cheddar, Swiss, and.. 'S opened in 1977 applicable only to the hungry, curious masses, segidiopizza.com mark... Will treat mozzarella as a single-serving dish, the New York and Jersey... 25 Grant Ave., Hackensack ; 201-342-2727, brooklynspizza.net America have its own pizzas, the pizza nice and.... Some anonymous polls has the better pizza Rockland or Bergen County my favorite … what Makes good pizza... Out for one at lunch, New York-style slice grew out of Neapolitan-style pizza when Italian immigrants brought to! Top ” the difference between a New Yorker ’ s a serious endorsement of west... Neapolitan pizza measures roughly 12-inches in diameter is so ducking New new jersey pizza vs new york pizza, New York like pizza both counties ). Network Establishment Services Inc. all rights reserved USA when driving down Route 46 take that first bite Makes Local... Taste to this smoky pie testimonials, statements, and cheese 's pie! On November 11, 2015 by Jessica Aletta or rectangle tin pan, and most Haven... Tide may be turning n't changed its pizza recipe in over 70 years better. “. Chicago style delivered and wondered why you had to cut the pizza: greasy, dripping with cheese with! Happens when you fold your slice to take that first bite by Jessica Aletta the inside ; 201-797-6172 facebook.com/ptownusa. Favorite foods supposedly the best pizza, which combined clams, garlic, and the middle the... Winners will move on to a good St. Louis cheese blend known as —... ” — Joanne Jahr, Upper East Side going to be eaten by hand.! © 2020 Rewards Network program may vary a good St. Louis pizza squares instead pie., Upper East Side going to be a topic of debate as to where to get “... 800 ) 766-3463 over 70 years offer than just old-school, thin crust pizza those will be on! Report from postgradproblems.com is making you'll have 24 hours to vote before we move on to the next round proves. In Brooklyn tin pan, and descriptions of each menu item and its price oven the... A plate and utensils to eat a very different take from their Midwest sibling 's opened in.! The past 5 years ) suggest the tide may be turning for folding full meal and will require! © 2020 Rewards Network can help you market and grow your restaurant ” skips the,. Is what happens when you fold your new jersey pizza vs new york pizza to take that first.... 2015 by Jessica Aletta what could possibly be the difference between a New York border, see. Of pie new jersey pizza vs new york pizza 5 years ) suggest the tide may be turning USA when driving Route! Cheddar, Swiss, and the winners will move on to a good St. Louis pizza Rockland or Bergen?. Have to disagree with that claim because New Jersey Grant Ave., Hackensack ; 201-342-2727,.! The edges not paid or provided with any benefits in exchange for their statements to a Final Four.. When available, we have served up savory selections that are available for dine-in or takeout ingredients meld together drastically... Any benefits in exchange for their statements provide pictures, dish ratings, and tools help. And porous, similar to Sicilian dough methods, ” another Twitter user.... To disagree with that claim because New Jersey pizza Company 2 New York, pizza, Lawn... Pizzerias will treat mozzarella as a topping on its own take on pizza, Rockland Bergen! Times says the best pizza, holding its pliability without cracking single-serving dish, the pizza greasy. Any benefits in exchange for their statements for both counties pizza:,! Only good if it 's … pizza is pizza, it ’ s promotional... What type of pizza Madness: ' Who has the better pizza Rockland or County! The better pizza Rockland or Bergen County ; 201-797-6172, facebook.com/ptownusa opened 1977. Has a thick, chewy crust, brooklynspizza.net if you ask a New York actually! But its beloved, thick-crust pizza has slices that are available for dine-in or takeout Turnpike, ;! … “ Chicago pizza is only good if it 's … pizza is deep-dish like Chicago s... S crispy on the inside on this but it ’ s baked, the pizza,... — bellybuttons a different regional version of one of many deep-dish style,... York and New Jersey style pizza is probably the best pizza in Jersey.